Sijbren Otto - Catalysis of Diels-Alder Reactions in Water
The Diels-Alder reaction of dienophiles 5.1a-e, containing neutral, cationic or anionic substituents, with diene 5.2 in the absence of Lewis acids is retarded by micelles of CTAB, SDS and C12E7. In the situation where the dienophile does not bind to the micelle, the reaction is inhibited because uptake of 5.2 in the micelles lowers its concentration in the aqueous phase. However, retardations are most pronounced when there is essentially complete binding of the dienophile to the micelle. In this case the reaction is likely to take place at the micellar surface, where it still experiences a water-like environment. The retardation mainly results from a significant difference in the binding locations of 5.1 and 5.2, with the dienophiles preferring the outer regions of the micelle and the diene residing in the interior. Evidence comes from solubilisate-induced aromatic shifts in the proton spectrum of the surfactants as well as from paramagnetic ion-induced relaxation rate enhancements of the 1H-NMR signals of the solubilisate. The latter experiments also show that 5.2, in contrast to 5.1, perturbs the micelles of SDS and Cu(DS)2. In the situation of inhomogeneous distribution of 5.1 and 5.2 over the micelle, kinetic analysis using the pseudophase model, that has been so successful for many other bimolecular micelle-catalysed processes, will lead to erroneous estimates of the second-order rate constant in the micellar pseudophase.
In contrast to the situation in the absence of catalytically active Lewis acids, micelles of Cu(DS)2 induce rate enhancements up to a factor 1.8·106 compared to the uncatalysed reaction in acetonitrile. These enzyme-like accelerations result from a very efficient complexation of the dienophile to the catalytically active copper ions, both species being concentrated at the micellar surface. Moreover, the higher affinity of 5.2 for Cu(DS)2 compared to SDS and CTAB (P5.2 = 96 versus 61 and 68, respectively) will diminish the inhibitory effect due to spatial separation of 5.1 and 5.2 as observed for SDS and CTAB.