Sijbren Otto - Catalysis of Diels-Alder Reactions in Water
Throughout this thesis reference has been made to hydrophobic effects. Enforced hydrophobic interactions are an important contributor to the acceleration of uncatalysed and also of the Lewis-acid catalysed Diels-Alder reactions which are described in this thesis. Moreover, they are likely to be involved in the beneficial effect of water on the enantioselectivity of the Lewis-acid catalysed Diels-Alder reaction, as described in Chapter 3. Because arguments related to hydrophobic effects are spread over nearly all chapters, and ideas have developed simultaneously, we summarise our insights at the end of this thesis.
Through the years, the molecular picture behind hydrophobic effects has been hidden under a cloak of misunderstandings which are for a large part of semantic origin. The effects are real, but have been given names that have contributed little to our understanding. Extremely misleading is the term “hydrophobic”, suggesting a phobia for water experienced by the solute. However, from the perspective of the solute, there is no phobia for water, in the sense that the interactions of the solute with the surrounding water molecules are comparable to- and sometimes even stronger than the interaction of the same solute molecule with its neighbours in the pure liquid state2. Hence, if it would be up to the solute to decide whether to interact with a neighbouring solute molecule in aqueous solution, or stay within its own hydration shell, it would choose the latter. Nevertheless, there exists a tendency for nonpolar molecules to stick together in aqueous solution (hydrophobic interaction). This cannot be a result of the interactions between the nonpolar molecules, but is imposed upon the solutes by water. It is the strong interaction between the water molecules that causes the low solubility of nonpolar compounds in water and squeezes the nonpolar molecules together.
A second important contributor to the misunderstanding of hydrophobic effects is the term “iceberg”, which is used in the discussion on the hydration of apolar molecules or groups. There exist strong indications for structuring of the water molecules in the direct vicinity of nonpolar solutes, but these water molecules are by no means frozen or more ice-like than bulk water. There are no experimental indications for a significant increase in the number or strength of the hydrogen bonds in the hydrophobic hydration shell. However, there are strong indications for a reduced entropy of the water molecules that make up these shells as compared to bulk water. Hence, structuring of hydration shell water exists, but only in an entropic sense.
In the hope of having done away with these misunderstandings, we now address the molecular origin of the hydrophobic hydration as well as the hydrophobic interaction. Note that comprehension of hydrophobic hydration is a prerequisite for understanding hydrophobic interactions, since hydrophobic interactions always involve a (partial) reversal of the hydrophobic hydration.
6.4.1 Hydrophobic hydration
If one would ask a chemist not burdened with any knowledge about the peculiar thermodynamics that characterise hydrophobic hydration, what would happen upon transfer of a nonpolar molecule from the gas phase to water, he or she would probably predict that this process is entropy driven and enthalpically highly unfavourable. This opinion, he or she would support with the suggestion that in order to create room for the nonpolar solute in the aqueous solution, hydrogen bonds between water molecules would have to be sacrificed.
The real situation is that, at ambient temperature, transfer of an ordinary nonpolar solute from the gas phase to water is characterised by a large reduction of the entropy and is enthalpically favourable. Apparently, water is capable of preventing the breaking of hydrogen bonds, but not without paying a price in the form of a reduction of the entropy. There are strong indications that this reduction in entropy can be attributed to the orientational constraints imposed upon the water molecules entangled in the hydrophobic hydration shells3. The number of orientations that these molecules can adopt while maintaining their hydrogen bonds with the surrounding water molecules is significantly reduced by the presence of the solute. Since the nonpolar solute cannot accept hydrogen bonds, keeping the fully hydrogen-bonded state is likely to lead to the observed orientation with one O-H bond parallel to the surface of the solute. Apparently, this arrangement in a hydrophobic hydration shell is favoured over the situation in which hydrogen bonds are broken.
However, if the formation of the hydrophobic hydration shell is hindered, the system prefers the sacrifice of hydrogen bonds. For instance, upon increasing the temperature, water tends towards the breaking of hydrogen bonds, as reflected by an increase of the enthalpy of hydration of nonpolar compounds with a concomitant less reduced hydration entropy. At higher temperatures, breaking of hydrogen bonds requires less additional energy, whereas the construction of an or a (in the editors’ view) relatively ordered hydrophobic hydration shell becomes increasingly difficult with increasing disorder in bulk water.
Similar effects are observed upon addition of cosolutes, such as salts and alcohols. The formation of hydrophobic hydration shells becomes increasingly unfavourable with increasing cosolute concentration. Apparently, the structural requirements of the hydrophobic hydration shell do not tolerate the presence of significant concentrations of foreign species in the aqueous solution.
Finally, also size and shape of the nonpolar solute seem to influence the formation of hydrophobic hydration shells. Particularly the curvature of the nonpolar surface has been suggested to be important4. Small spherical particles allow the formation of a hydrophobic hydration shell, without a significant sacrifice of hydrogen bonds. As the curvature of the nonpolar surface decreases, the extent of breaking of hydrogen bonds increases. Hydration of a flat surface is characterised by a significant number of dangling hydrogen bonds5. In the extreme of a nonpolar cavity, it is evident that upon entering, the water molecules sacrifice hydrogen bonds. Hence, hydration of these cavities will be characterised by a or an (in the editors’ view) unfavourable enthalpy change6.
Although temperature, cosolutes and curvature have dramatic effects on the entropy and enthalpy of hydration of nonpolar solutes, these effects largely compensate each other, so that the Gibbs energy is much less affected. Hence, the Gibbs energy of the state in which a hydrophobic hydration shell is formed is only slightly lower than that of the situation where hydrogen bonds are sacrificed instead.
6.4.2 Hydrophobic interactions
Interactions between nonpolar compounds are generally stronger in water than in organic solvents. At concentrations where no aggregation or phase separation takes place, pairwise hydrophobic interactions can occur. Under these conditions, the lowest energy state for a solute molecule is the one in which it is completely surrounded by water molecules. However, occasionally, it will also meet other solute molecules, and form short-lived encounter complexes. In water, the lifetime of these complexes exceeds that in organic solvents, since the partial desolvation that accompanies the formation of these complexes is less unfavourable in water than in organic solvents.
Pairwise hydrophobic interactions can be used to alter the reactivity of organic molecules in water. For instance, the rate of hydrolysis reactions may be influenced significantly by the presence of hydrophobic cosolutes7. The effect on reactivity has been analysed by comparing the interactions between initial state and cosolute with those between transition state and cosolute7.
When the concentration of the nonpolar solute is increased, the entropy of mixing of the newly added molecules that drives the dissolution process, gradually diminishes. At a certain critical concentration, the entropy of mixing is insufficient to overcome the unfavourable Gibbs energy of hydration. At this concentration, phase separation will set in. Depending on the molecular structure of the solute, this process can result in the formation of a two-phase system, or the formation of an aggregated pseudophase. In water, the interactions that drive phase separation are referred to as bulk hydrophobic interactions. Also these interactions can be used to influence organic reactivity as exemplified by catalytic effects of aggregates. These aggregates affect the rate of organic reactions by providing a reaction medium different from that of bulk water. For monomolecular reactions this medium effect can be large. However, for bimolecular reactions the effect on the intrinsic reactivity is usually modest. Nevertheless, the effects of aggregates on the rates of bimolecular reactions can be large when the reactants are gathered in or around the aggregates. Note that also the binding of nonpolar compounds to aggregates is governed by hydrophobic interactions. In this case the hydrophobic interactions are associated with a partitioning between two (pseudo)phases, and as such, cannot be ranked under pairwise (binding to the aggregates is not transient) or bulk (as long as the solute concentration is lower than the solubility limit) hydrophobic interactions.
A third kind of hydrophobic interaction occurs when a chemical reaction happens to force two nonpolar molecules together. Enforced hydrophobic interactions ensure that the rate of these reactions in water is increased as compared to organic solvents. Note that in a chemical reaction, the entropic price for the association of two hydrophobic compounds is part of the activation process. For irreversible reactions the association is permanent, which distinguishes enforced hydrophobic interactions from pairwise hydrophobic interactions. The aqueous Diels-Alder reaction is one of the most well-documented examples in which enforced hydrophobic interactions are operative. For this transformation, strong indications exist that the reaction centre entirely loses its nonpolar character in the activation process7a,8. In terms of transition state theory, the initial state of the reaction in water is destabilised relative to that in organic solvents. In the transition state this effect is largely absent, so that the activation energy of the Diels-Alder reaction in water is reduced as compared to organic solvents.
The observation that in the activated complex the reaction centre has lost its hydrophobic character, can have important consequences. The retro Diels-Alder reaction, for instance, will also benefit from the breakdown of the hydrophobic hydration shell during the activation process. The initial state of this reaction has a nonpolar character. Due to the principle of microscopic reversibility, the activated complex of the retro Diels-Alder reaction is identical to that of the bimolecular Diels-Alder reaction which means this complex has a negligible nonpolar character near the reaction centre. Consequently, also in the activation process of the retro Diels-Alder reaction a significant breakdown of hydrophobic hydration takes place9. Note that for this process the volume of activation is small, which implies that the number of water molecules involved in hydration of the reacting system does not change significantly in the activation process.
We conclude that the beneficial effects of water are not necessarily limited to reactions that are characterised by a negative volume of activation. We infer that, apart from the retro Diels-Alder reaction also other reactions, in which no significant reduction or perhaps even an increase of solvent accessible surface area takes place, can be accelerated by water. A reduction of the nonpolar nature during the activation process is a prerequisite in these cases.
In the case of the retro Diels-Alder reaction, the nature of the activated complex plays a key role. In the activation process of this transformation, the reaction centre undergoes changes, mainly in the electron distributions, that cause a lowering of the chemical potential of the surrounding water molecules. Most likely, the latter is a consequence of an increased interaction between the reaction centre and the water molecules. Since the enforced hydrophobic effect is entropic in origin, this implies that the orientational constraints of the water molecules in the hydrophobic hydration shell are relieved in the activation process. Hence, it almost seems as if in the activated complex, the hydrocarbon part of the reaction centre is involved in hydrogen bonding interactions. Note that the transition state of a Diels-Alder reaction resembles an aromatic system10 and that there is evidence for hydrogen bond formation to aromatic systems11. If this is true, this would shed a whole new light on the way in which water can affect rates of organic reactions. Detailed studies to verify this intriguing suggestion are urgently required.
Also the arene-arene interactions, as encountered in Chapter 3, are partly due to hydrophobic effects, which can be ranked among enforced hydrophobic interactions. Simultaneous coordination of an aromatic α-amino acid ligand and the dienophile to the central copper(II) ion offers the possibility of a reduction of the number of water molecules involved in hydrophobic hydration, leading to a strengthening of the arene-arene interaction. Hence, hydrophobic effects can have a beneficial influence on the enantioselectivity of organic reactions. This effect is anticipated to extend well beyond the Diels-Alder reaction.