Перейти к основному содержанию
Вся химия

6.3 Lewis acid - Lewis base interactions in water. Implications for catalysis

Sijbren Otto - Catalysis of Diels-Alder Reactions in Water

This thesis has been completely devoted to catalysis by relatively hard catalysts. When aiming at the catalysis of Diels-Alder reactions, soft catalysts are not an option. Soft catalysts tend to coordinate directly to the carbon - carbon double bonds of diene and dienophile, leading to an activation towards nucleophilic attack rather than to a Diels-Alder reaction1. This is unfortunate, since in water, catalysis by hard catalysts suffers from a number of intrinsic disadvantages, which are absent for soft catalysts.

6.3.1 Hard Lewis acids and bases

Water molecules unite in them hard, strongly Lewis-basic, as well as hard, strongly Lewis-acidic sites. In the solid and the liquid state of water, interactions between these sites result in the formation of a hydrogen-bond network, to which water owes its unique properties. Solutes that are capable of interacting efficiently with these hard sites, generally exhibit a high solubility in water. This conclusion applies in particular to salts containing hard ions. Water is one of the most efficient solvents in weakening the interaction between hard positive and hard negative charges.

Analogously, water is extremely efficient in weakening hard Lewis acid - hard Lewis base interactions. Consequently, when aiming at catalysis by hard Lewis acids, the inefficiency of the interaction between the catalyst and the substrate is a serious problem. Strangely enough, this characteristic of water is not recognised by many researchers working with hard Lewis acids in aqueous solutions. Particularly the use of the extremely hard trivalent lanthanide cations has recently received considerable attention in synthetic organic chemistry (see Section 2.1.1). In aqueous solution, these ions are observed to induce an increase in yields and selectivities of a large number of organic reactions, from which it is concluded that Lewis-acid catalysis is operative. Unfortunately, for the majority of these reactions, no direct evidence of an interaction between catalyst and substrate is provided. Regarding the structure of most of the employed reactants, such an interaction is expected to be extremely weak, if present at all. Note that even the bidentate 3-phenyl-1-(2-pyridyl)-2-propene-1-one dienophiles employed in this thesis have a negligible tendency to interact with lanthanide ions in aqueous solution. Hence, the term “Lewis-acid catalysis” might well be ill-chosen for many of these reactions. Most likely, the beneficial effects of the Lewis-acidic ions on these processes is or are (in the editors’ view) indirect. In many of the reactions that have been reported to benefit from Lewis-acids in aqueous media, such as the aldol reaction, the Michael addition and the Mannich reaction, proton-transfer steps are involved. It might well be that mainly these steps are affected by the presence of Lewis-acid catalysts in water. Note also that aqueous solutions of salts of multivalent cations contain a significant amount of metal-ion coordinated hydroxide ions together with a similar amount of H3O+. In other words, Lewis acids enhance the dissociation of water. Reactions involving proton transfer steps are likely to be influenced in such media.

Turning the argument around: reactions that do not involve proton transfer steps will only experience a significant effect of the Lewis acids if a direct interaction exists between catalyst and reactant. The conventional Diels-Alder reaction is a representative of this class of reactions. As long as monodentate reactants are used, the effects of Lewis acids on this reaction do not exceed the magnitude expected for simple salt effects, i.e. there are no indications for a direct interaction between Lewis-acid and substrate.

We conclude that, when employing hard Lewis-acids in aqueous solution, the term “Lewis-acid catalysis” should be used with caution, and only after evidence for a direct interaction between Lewis-acid and substrate has been obtained.

However, once coordination of the substrate to the Lewis-acid catalyst has been achieved, the use of aqueous media can have marked benefits over organic solvents. For instance, separation of product and catalyst is usually facilitated. Significantly, the fact that water is so efficient in breaking interactions between Lewis acids and Lewis bases (and also electrostatic interactions) turns into a considerable benefit. In organic solvents, enhanced interaction of catalytically active ions with counterions tends to hamper the interaction with the substrate. In water, these ion pairing effects are largely absent. Clustering of the catalytic species is another complication that can be encountered in organic solvents, but is infrequent in water. Consequently, mechanistic investigations of catalytic processes tend to be less complicated in water than in organic solvents.

6.3.2 Soft Lewis acids and bases

In contrast to the extreme efficiency with which water breaks up interactions between hard Lewis acids and hard Lewis bases, it has only little influence on the interactions between soft Lewis acids and soft Lewis bases. Small and poorly polarisable water molecules are not able to interact strongly with large polarisable entities. Consequently, reactions in which catalysis proceeds through interaction of the catalyst with apolar but polarisable parts of organic molecules, such as carbon - carbon double bonds, need not fear interference of water. Hence, reactions like hydrogenations and hydroformylations, catalysed by soft catalyst or catalysts (in the editors’ view) containing palladium, rhodium or ruthenium centres, can be successfully performed in aqueous solution. However, the absence of efficient interactions between water and the catalyst gives rise to problems with regard to the solubility of the catalyst. As a result, many of the ligands that are employed in these processes need to be equipped with highly polar or ionic groups to ensure water solubility.