Skip to main content
All Chemistry

6.2 Goals and achievements

Sijbren Otto - Catalysis of Diels-Alder Reactions in Water

At the outset of the work described in this thesis we formulated a number of questions.

First of all, given the well recognised promoting effects of Lewis-acids and of aqueous solvents on Diels-Alder reactions, we wanted to know if these two effects could be combined. If this would be possible, dramatic improvements of rate and endo-exo selectivity were envisaged.

Studies on the Diels-Alder reaction of a dienophile, specifically designed for this purpose are described in Chapter 2. It is demonstrated that Lewis-acid catalysis in an aqueous medium is indeed feasible and, as anticipated, can result in impressive enhancements of both rate and endo-exo selectivity. However, the influences of the Lewis-acid catalyst and the aqueous medium are not fully additive. It seems as if water diminishes the catalytic potential of Lewis acids just as coordination of a Lewis acid diminishes the beneficial effects of water. Still, overall, the rate of the catalysed reaction in water is faster than in most organic solvents, justifying further development of Lewis-acid catalysis of Diels-Alder reactions in water.

A second question involves the influence of ligands on the rate and selectivity of the Lewis-acid catalysed Diels-Alder reaction in water. In Chapter 3 we have demonstrated that nearly all the ligands studied induce a significant decrease in the affinity of the catalyst for the dienophile. This effect is accompanied by a modest reduction of the rate of the Diels-Alder reaction of the ternary dienophile - catalyst - ligand complex.

Most significantly, one class of ligands, the aromatic α-amino acids, shows deviating behaviour due to a specific ligand - dienophile interaction. This interaction can be employed successfully in enantioselective catalysis, allowing, for the first time, the effect of aqueous solvents on the enantioselectivity of a chiral Lewis-acid catalysed reaction to be studied. It turned out that water is capable of inducing a significant increase in the enantioselectivity as compared to organic solvents. Of all the work described in this thesis, this discovery is probably the most significant. Given the fact that the arene - arene interactions underlying the observed enantioselectivity of the Diels-Alder reactions described in Chapter 3 are also encountered in other organic reactions, we infer that, in the near future, the beneficial influence of water on enantioselectivity can also be extended to these transformations. Moreover, the fact that water can now be used as a solvent for enantioselective Lewis-acid catalysed reactions facilitates mechanistic studies of these processes, because the number of equilibria that need to be considered is reduced. Furthermore, knowledge and techniques from aqueous coordination chemistry can now be used directly in enantioselective catalysis.

Having observed the beneficial effects of water on the rate and enantioselectivity of one particular Diels-Alder reaction, an answer to the third question, addressing the scope of Lewis-acid catalysis of Diels-Alder reactions in water, became all the more desirable. Chapter 4 describes an investigation of the limitations of this process. It is concluded that in water efficient catalysis is feasible only for Diels-Alder reactants capable of bi- or multidentate binding to the catalyst. Unfortunately, hardly any common diene or dienophile fulfils this requirement. In an attempt to extend the scope of Lewis-acid catalysis in water we made use of a strongly chelating diamine as a coordinating auxiliary, introduced via a Mannich reaction. This approach may well be expected to subject those dienes or dienophiles capable of undergoing a Mannich reaction with 2-(methylaminomethyl)pyridine to Lewis-acid catalysis in water. However, enantioselective Lewis-acid catalysis employing the copper - aromatic α-amino acid complexes introduced in Chapter 3 is unlikely to be successful for these compounds. The Mannich adducts coordinate in a tridentate fashion. In this arrangement a geometry resembling that shown in Scheme 3.10 is unlikely. In conclusion, at this moment the scope of Lewis-acid catalysis in aqueous solution is still rather limited.

Finally, in Chapter 5, micellar catalysis of Diels-Alder reactions is discussed. In view of the nonpolar nature of most Diels-Alder reactants, efficient micellar catalysis of this reaction was anticipated. However, this has not been observed. The results for the Diels-Alder reaction between cyclopentadiene and substituted 3-phenyl-1-(2-pyridyl)-2-propene-1-one dienophiles, discussed in Chapter 5, may provide a rationale. Conclusions derived from a number of 1H-NMR measurements indicate that cyclopentadiene has a high affinity for the interior of the micelles that were investigated, whereas the dienophile prefers the outer regions. In view of the structures of most dienes and dienophiles such a spatial separation can be expected for the majority of Diels-Alder reactions. This arrangement accounts for the unexpectedly small influence of micelles on the rates of Diels-Alder reactions as reported in the literature.

Chapter 5 also demonstrates that a combination of Lewis-acid catalysis and micellar catalysis can lead to accelerations of enzyme-like magnitudes. Most likely, these accelerations are a consequence of an efficient interaction between the Lewis-acid catalyst and the dienophile, both of which have a high affinity for the Stern region of the micelle. Hence, hydrophobic interactions and Lewis-acid catalysis act cooperatively. Unfortunately, the strength of the hydrophobic interaction, as offered by the Cu(DS)2 micellar system, was not sufficient for extension of Lewis-acid catalysis to monodentate dienophiles.

In summary, the work in this thesis provides an overview of what can be achieved with Lewis-acid and micellar catalysis for Diels-Alder reactions in water as exemplified by the reaction of 3-phenyl-1-(2-pyridyl)-2-propene-1-ones with cyclopentadiene. Extension of the observed beneficial effect of water on rates and particularly enantioselectivities to other systems is envisaged.