Перейти к основному содержанию
Вся химия

1.5 Lewis acid - Lewis base coordination in water

Sijbren Otto - Catalysis of Diels-Alder Reactions in Water

In a Lewis-acid catalysed Diels-Alder reaction, the first step is coordination of the catalyst to a Lewis-basic site of the reactant. In a typical catalysed Diels-Alder reaction, the carbonyl oxygen of the dienophile coordinates to the Lewis acid. The most common solvents for these processes are inert apolar liquids such as dichloromethane or benzene. Protic solvents, and water in particular, are avoided because of their strong interactions with the catalyst and the reacting system. Interestingly, for other catalysed reactions such as hydroformylations the same solvents do not give problems. This paradox is a result of the difference in hardness of the reactants and the catalyst involved.

1.5.1 Hard-Soft Acid-Base (HSAB) theory

The Hard-Soft-Acid-Base (HSAB) theory was developed by Pearson in 1963201. According to this theory, Lewis acids and Lewis bases are divided into two groups: on one hand hard acids and bases, which are usually small, weakly polarizable species with highly localised charges, and on the other hand soft acids and bases which are large, polarizable species with delocalised charges. A selection of Lewis acids, ordered according to their hardness in aqueous solution is presented in Table 1.3200.

Table 1.3. Classification of the hardness in aqueous solution of some selected Lewis-acids according to the HSAB theorya.

hardborderlinesoft
H+Fe2+Cu+
Fe3+Ni2+Hg+
Co3+Cu2+Cd+ or Cd2+ (in the editors’ view)
Al3+Zn2+
La3+

a Data taken from Ref. 201a.

The theory predicts high stabilities for hard acid - hard base complexes, mainly resulting from electrostatic interactions and for soft acid - soft base complexes, where covalent bonding is also important. Hard acid - soft base and hard base - soft acid complexes usually have low stability. Unfortunately, in a quantitative sense, the predictive value of the HSAB theory is limited. Thermodynamic analysis clearly shows a difference between hard-hard interactions and soft-soft interactions. In water hard-hard interactions are usually endothermic and occur only as a result of a gain in entropy, originating from a liberation of water molecules from the hydration shells of the Lewis acid and the ligand. By contrast, soft-soft interactions are mainly enthalpic in origin and are characterised by a negative change in entropy202.

Several alternative attempts have been made to quantify Lewis-acid Lewis-base interaction203. In view of the HSAB theory, the applicability of a scale which describes Lewis acidity with only one parameter will be unavoidably restricted to a narrow range of structurally related Lewis bases. The use of more than one parameter results in relationships with a more general validity204. However, a quantitative prediction of the gas-phase stabilities of Lewis-acid Lewis-base complexes is still difficult. Hence the interpretation, not to mention the prediction, of solvent effects on Lewis-acid Lewis-base interactions remains largely speculative.

1.5.2 Coordination in water versus organic solvents

The most effective Lewis-acid catalysts for the Diels-Alder reaction are hard cations. Not surprisingly, they coordinate to hard nuclei on the reacting system, typically oxygen atoms. Consequently, hard solvents are likely to affect these interactions significantly205. Table 1.4 shows a selection of some solvents ranked according to their softness. Note that water is one of the hardest solvents known.

Table 1.4. Softness of some selected solvents according to the µ-scalea.

solventµ
water0.00b
methanol0.02
dichloromethane0.1 - 0.2c
dimethyl sulfoxide0.22
benzene0.3 - 0.4c
acetonitrile0.35

a Data taken from Ref. 206, derived from a comparison of ΔGtr° (water → solvent) for Ag+ with the mean of ΔGtr° (water → solvent) for Na+ and K+. b By definition. c Only approximate values are reported.

Solvents are able to affect Lewis-acid Lewis-base equilibria through a number of non-covalent interactions. First, the solvent can act as a Lewis base itself, by coordinating to the catalyst. Analogous to the Lewis acidity scales, solvents have been ranked according to their Lewis-basicity. These scales, as far as they try to quantify Lewis-basicity by using only one parameter, have limited validity. The electron-pair donor ability and Lewis-basicity scales of solvents are discussed in ref. 61 and 207. In Table 1.5 a number of Lewis acidity or Lewis basicity (in the editors’ view) parameters of some relevant solvents are compared. Aprotic and apolar solvents coordinate relatively weakly to the catalyst, whereas polar solvents exhibit stronger interactions. Note that water, as bulk liquid, is among the most strongly Lewis-basic solvents when hard-hard interactions are considered. These interactions have to be disrupted before the Diels-Alder reactant can coordinate to the Lewis acid. Furthermore, steric interactions between the coordinated Diels-Alder reactant and coordinated solvent molecules are important in determining the stability of the complex208. Consequently, catalysis by Lewis acids in solvents that coordinate strongly to the catalyst will be less effective.

Table 1.5. Donor scales (DS, DN and DNBULK) of some selected solvents, as well as acceptor number (AN) and hydrogen bond donor capacities (α).

DSaDNbDNBULKcANdαe
dichloromethane620.40.00
benzene90.10.88.2(0.30)
acetonitrile1214.111.119.30.19
water1718.040.354.81.17
methanol181931.341.30.93
dimethylsulfoxide27.529.82719.30.00

a Donor strengths, taken from ref. 207b, based upon the solvent effect on the symmetric stretching frequency of the soft Lewis acid HgBr2. b Gutmann's donor number taken from ref. 207b, based upon ΔHr for the process of coordination of an isolated solvent molecule to the moderately hard SbCl5 molecule in dichloroethane. c Bulk donor number calculated as described in ref. 209 from the solvent effect on the adsorption or absorption (in the editors’ view) spectrum of VO(acac)2. d Taken from ref. 58, based on the 31P NMR chemical shift of triethylphosphine oxide in the respective pure solvent. e Taken from ref. 61, based on the solvatochromic shift of a pyridinium-N-phenoxide betaine dye.

The second important influence of the solvent on Lewis acid - Lewis base equilibria concerns the interactions with the Lewis base. Consequently the Lewis acidity and, for hard Lewis bases, especially the hydrogen bond donor capacity of the solvent are important parameters. The electron pair acceptor capacities, quantified by the acceptor number AN, together with the hydrogen bond donor acidities, α, of some selected solvents are listed in Table 1.5. Water is among the solvents with the highest AN and, accordingly, interacts strongly with Lewis bases. This seriously hampers the efficiency of Lewis-acid catalysis in water.

Thirdly, the intramolecular or intermolecular (in the editors’ view) association of a solvent affects the Lewis acid - base equilibrium210. Upon complexation, one or more solvent molecules that were initially coordinated to the Lewis acid or the Lewis base are liberated into the bulk liquid phase, which is entropically favourable. This effect is more pronounced in aprotic solvents than in protic solvents, which usually have a higher cohesive energy density. The less favourable entropy change in protic solvents is somewhat counteracted by the more favourable enthalpy change upon release of a coordinated solvent molecule into the bulk liquid, resulting from the newly formed hydrogen bonds.

Finally, the solvent also interacts with sites of the Lewis acid and the Lewis base that are not directly involved in mutual coordination, thereby altering the electronic properties of the complex. For example, delocalisation of charges into the surrounding solvent molecules causes ions in solution to be softer than in the gas phase208. Again, water is particularly effective since it can act as an efficient electron pair acceptor as well as a donor.

In summary, water is clearly an extremely bad solvent for coordination of a hard Lewis acid to a hard Lewis base. Hence, catalysis of Diels-Alder reactions in water is expected to be difficult due to the relative inefficiency of the interactions between the Diels-Alder reactants and the Lewis-acid catalyst in this medium.