Перейти до основного вмісту
Вся хімія

6.5 Prospects and incentives to future research

Sijbren Otto - Catalysis of Diels-Alder Reactions in Water

As a result of the growing need for clean chemistry, the use of catalytic processes is becoming increasingly popular and alternatives for organic solvents are being sought. Consequently, Lewis-acid catalysis in water is expected to be a field of considerable interest in the near future. Clearly, catalysis by soft Lewis acids in water is generally easier than catalysis by hard catalysts. In the slip stream of the success of the Ruhr Chemie Rhone-Poulenc process, more breakthroughs in the former field can be expected in the coming years, whereas catalysis by hard Lewis acids in aqueous media will remain troublesome for the time being. The use of substrates with non-chelating functionalities in reactions catalysed by hard Lewis acids is a big challenge for the future. Perhaps the use of binuclear catalysts can break the deadlock12. The occurrence of a reverse chelate effect has been reported for these systems, which can lead to more pronounced selectivities in binding of monodentate compounds13.

It might also be possible to employ the hydrophobic effect for selective binding of a reactant to the catalyst. Interestingly, Menger et al.14 have recently used combinatorially developed catalysts for reductions and hydrolysis reactions. For the reduction of ketones in aqueous solution, the most active catalyst libraries were those that contained both hydrophobic constituents, as well as moieties exhibiting a large affinity for catalytically active metal ions14b. In this thesis another example of the beneficial influence of hydrophobic effects on catalyst - substrate binding is encountered in the form of micelles, containing catalytically active counterions.

Finally, if there could be a way in which in water selective η2 π-coordination to the carbonyl group of an α,β-unsaturated ketone can be achieved, this would be a breakthrough, since it would subject monodentate reactants to catalysis by hard Lewis acids15.

Developments along these three lines can be expected to greatly extend the yet limited utility of catalysis by hard Lewis acids in aqueous media. The work described in this thesis has demonstrated that these efforts can be rewarded by increased or increases (in the editors’ view) in rate and most importantly, enantioselectivity.

We would like to conclude this thesis with the expression of the hope that in its course, we have taken away some of the “hydrophobia” that stills or still (in the editors’ view) exists among organic chemists, although we admit that we might have replaced it with more rational arguments. Nevertheless, the treasure can make it worthwhile to slay the dragon.